list of murders in british columbia

: police", "RCMP searching York Landing, Man., for B.C. Luke Neville was last seen in Spences Bridge on October 9, 2017 and his burned out white 2003 Ford E250 van was found on the Sackum Forest service road 20km from his home the following day. The corpse of an unidentified white female between the ages of 1825 years old was found in a ditch along a rural highway near Napanee, Ontario. He died in Oregon Prison in 2006, having only been definitively charged with the murder of one 16 year-old girl. On the evening of November 28, 1990, two armed and masked men forcibly entered Henri's home. [38][39] By August 12, an autopsy report from Winnipeg confirmed that the two bodies found belonged to the wanted suspects and that they died of self-inflicted gunshot wounds. BAUMGARTNER, William A - RCMP detachments starting with the letter A; B - RCMP detachments starting with the letter B; C - RCMP detachments starting with the letter C; D - RCMP detachments starting with the letter D; E - RCMP detachments starting with the letter E After abducting his victims two at time, he supposedly ordered them to choose which one would be sexually assaulted. She was a prostitute in the area. [5][6], In the summer of 2019, Australian national Lucas Fowler and his girlfriend, American national Chynna Deese, were taking a three-week trip around Canada. [49] The locations of the murders were incorrectly identified as taking place on or near the infamous Highway of Tears. Her killer was never apprehended, but the investigation exposed police corruption and the ugly undercurrent of racism. He was a suspect in the murders of Craig Palmer and Tyrone King a year prior. [14] The body of Vancouver resident Leonard Dyck was found 2km (1.2mi) south of the vehicle fire, with "similar circumstances" as Fowler and Deese (whose bodies were found 470km (290mi) away). Maurice Richard Tremblay, Prince Rupert It was mechanical issues with the van. Naomi's nude body was found on March 27, 1987, in a ditch near the city dump. Search and rescue teams scoured the area, including crews from Nicola Valley, Kamloops, Shuswap, Central Okanagan, Penticton, Princeton, Logan Lake, Chilliwack and Surrey. The lake is between Kamloops and Merritt. the Murderpedia project stay alive. At 12:08 am on May 3, 2008, police officers heard gunshots near Sunrise Walk and Olympic Court in north Halifax. Jane Johnson, along with her daughter, Cathryn, were murdered in their home on the evening of September 3, 1996. Her clothing was scattered around her, and a suitcase with her possessions was found nearby. Most of his victims were sex trade workers and drug addicts of whom he had invited back to his farm, often with more than one guest at a time. [18] Following this discovery, the RCMP sought second-degree murder charges against McLeod and Schmegelsky in relation to the British Columbia killings. Murders in 2022 So Far: 132(2021 Total: 116)Male Victims: 90Female Victims: 25Unknown: 17, The British Columbia Murder Victim List 2021 is available here, January1 Julian Moya Cardenas, Male, 18, Shooting, Langley2 Ryan Lajeunesse, Male, 41, Stabbing, Abbotsford3 Brian Chapman, Male, 63, Shooting Surrey4 Unknown Victim, Vernon5 Carmelita Abraham, Female, Quesnel6 John Doe, Male, 77, Shooting, Richmond7 Jane Doe, Female, 58, Shooting, Richmond8 Jane Doe, 21, Shooting, Richmond9 John Doe, Male, Prince George10 Jane Doe, Stabbing Coquitlam11 Jagraj Dhinsa, Male, 18, Kamloops12 Dillion Loehndorf, Male, Shooting, Terrace, February13 Codi Carlyle Rogers, Female, 40, Mission 14 Dana Gilbertson, Male, Shooting, Delta15 Juvraj Jabal, Male, 24, Shooting, Surrey16 Sarbjeet Sander, Male, 57, Langley17 Jane Doe, Female, 39, Fort St. James18 Eric Kutzner, Male, 79, Nanaimo19 Cody Corbett, Male, 30, Abbotsford20 Shu-Min Wu, Female, 50, Shooting, Vancouver21 Ying Ying Sun, Female, 39, Shooting, Vancouver22 John Doe, Male, Keremeos23 Terry Miller, Male, 66, Stabbing, Coquitlam24 Harmandeep Kaur, Female, 24, Kelowna 25 John Doe, Male, 36, Shooting, Fort St. James26 Jane Doe, Female, 56, Erickson, March27 John Doe, Male, Stabbing, Victoria28 Jane Doe, Female, 80, Courtenay29 Sidney Mantee, Male, 33, Reported Missing in 2020, Nanaimo30 Milad Rahimi, Male, Shooting, North Vancouver31 John Doe, Male, Lillooet32 Chad Colivas, Male, 41, Shooting, Abbotsford33 Mohd Abdullah, Male, Kamloops34 John Doe, Male, Surrey35 Cody William Mostat, Male, Langley36 Nicholas Ball, 29, Male, Langley37- John Doe, Male, Prince George38 Joo Daniel Jeon, Male, 41, Coquitlam, April39 Christopher Raymond Hartl, Male, 48, Shooting, Surrey40 David Goldstein, Male, Shooting, Surrey41 Darr Khunkhun, Male, Shooting, Maple Ridge42 John Doe, Male, Stabbing, Kelowna43 Arthur Aaron Joseph Comeau, Male, Shooting, Maple Ridge, May44 Jian Ying Angela Du,, Female, 51, Stabbing, Vancouver45 John Doe, Male, Stabbing, Williams Lake46 Andrew Wadden, Male, 45, Vancouver47 John Doe, Male, Stabbing, Coquitlam48 Arnold De Jong, Male, 77, Abbotsford49 Joanne De Jong, Female, 76, Abbotsford50 John Doe, Male, Sooke51 Naseb Fazil, Male, 19, Stabbing, Vancouver52 John Doe, Abbotsford 53 Michael Gordon Brown, Male, 58, Shooting, Surrey54 Maanav Kinkar, 18, Male, Surrey55 Wolf-Ingo Rudolf Beyer, Male, Vernon, June56 Kevin Allaraj, Shooting Richmond57 Jeevan Saepan, Shooting Richmond58 Zachary Trimble, Male, 23, Stabbing, Vancouver59 John Doe, Male, 38, Shooting, Vernon60 John Doe, Male, 61, Oliver61 Unknown Victim Campbell River62 John Doe, Male, Stabbing, Prince George63 Jane Doe, Female, Nanaimo64 Unknown Victim, Peachland65 Scott Carver, Male, 52, Vancouver66 Mehdi Damien Eslahian, Male, 37, Shooting, Port Coquitlam, July 67 Mohamed Abdulrahman Mohamed, Male, 28, Shooting, Surrey68 Justin Mohrmann, Male, 29, Stabbing, Vancouver69 Ripudaman Singh Malik, Male, Shooting, Surrey70 Christopher Irwin, 31, Burnaby71 John Doe, Male, 33, Stabbing, Duncan72 Cashmere Ali, Female, Maple Ridge73 Amber Culley, Female, 43, Shooting, Chilliwack74 Mimi Kates, Female, 49, Shooting, Chilliwack75 Zane Ponecappo, Male, 29, Stabbing, Vancouver76 Meninder Dhaliwal, Shooting, Whistler77 Satindera Gill, Shooting, Whistler78 Paul David Wynn Langley79 Steven Furness, Langley80 Kamaljit Sandhu, Female, 45, Abbotsford81 Jordan Krishna, 19, Male, Shooting, Surrey82 Unknown Victim, Male, Kelowna83 Robeen Soreni, 20, Shooting, Surrey, BC, August84 Meysam Zaki, 18, Male, Burnaby85 David Chavez-Jara, Male, 30, Shooting, Surrey86 Cory William Thomas, Male, 33, Shooting, Maple Ridge87 John Doe, Male, Kelowna88 Trevor Stross, 40, Other, Nanaimo89 Jean-Luc Noel Levesque, Male, 51, Castlegar90 John Doe Male, 45, Stabbing, Surrey91 John Doe, Stabbing, Mission92 Frank James, Male, 47, Surrey93 John Doe, Male, Shooting, Kamloops94 Troy Regnier,Male, 37, Surrey95 Mani Amar, Male, Beating, Surrey96 Unknown Victim Summerland97 Unknown Victim Summerland, September98 John Doe, Male, Stabbing, Abbotsford99 John Doe, Male, 29, Stabbing, Nanaimo100 John Doe, Male, Burnaby101 Unknown Victim, Penticton102 Unknown Victim, Penticton103 Richard Ofosuhene, Male, Shooting, Surrey104 Shaun Hoole, Male, 51, Egmont, B.C.105 Jane Doe, 72, Enderby, October105 Shemar Jack, Male, Shooting, Richmond106 John Doe, Male, Dawson Creek107 Vishal Walia, Shooting, UBC Endowment Lands108 Kiesha Garie , Male, 31, Burnaby109 Umair Kasim, Male, 30, Burnaby110 RCMP Cst. The search for Angel didn't begin for weeks, as the, Cynthia Kudjick was found on January 3, 2005. In comparison, the national average is 70.96 in all of Canada, having gone up by 137 in the last year. murder suspects charged with 2nd-degree murder of Leonard Dyck in Dease Lake case", "B.C. It ranks 9/229 on the Crime Severity Index in all of Canada, compared to the average of 70.96 in all of Canada, having gone up by 157 in the last year. One notable victim was 15-year-old Jackie English, who disappeared in October 1969, and was found in a creek five days after being reported missing. Despite extensive searches and investigations, only two bodies have turned up and the Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP) remain baffled. New Brunswick N.S. Canada is the second largest country in the world according to land mass, and is considered to be a safe country. Its close enough to feel like youre living in Vancouver without facing any of the realities about its housing market. His murder is considered to be a completely random act of violence. [4] Between July 23 and August 7, McLeod and Schmegelsky used firearms to commit suicide near the Nelson River, northeast of Gillam, Manitoba. It measures both the seriousness and volume of each offence. [42] By July 27, an RCAF 435 Transport and Rescue Squadron CC-130H Hercules aircraft was deployed from Winnipeg for aerial reconnaissance to the Gillam area, while following RCMP requests. As a multicultural city, Vancouverites are known for being a laidback, easy-going bunch. The bodies of two boys were found concealed at Stanley Park in 1953, six years after the time they were actually murdered. Three murder victims were discovered in East Vancouver in 1995, all of whom were prostitutes that had worked in the same area of Vancouver. murder suspects shrinking but not ending", "How a river guide's sharp eye, and a sleeping bag, triggered a search that ended the RCMP manhunt", "RCMP find items linked to B.C. On the early morning of October 29, 1924, an explosion on the remote. Series of murders in Northern British Columbia, Canada, "Timeline: Triple murders committed in B.C. Contrary to what the locals say, Richmond is not a city that will slide into the ocean when the Big One hits. [10] Broughton was assured that the couple knew what they were doing, and saw them "happy" and "smiling" before leaving them shortly after. Allukpik stated that he "hated women", and his motive was to "take his anger out on [Rhoda]". Her body was found in a shallow grave in a nearby park in October 1994. List of unsolved murders in Canada B Babes in the Wood murders (Stanley Park) Bacon Brothers (gangsters) Lynn Breeden C Ranjit Cheema D Chynna Deese Shirley Duguay F Harold Ernest Forster Lucas Fowler H Tara Singh Hayer William C. Hopkinson J Bindy Johal L Pat Lowther M Robert McBeath P Nasrat Parsa S Louie Sam Gurmit Singh Dhak T Jonathan Thorn The breaking and entering rate for every 100,000 people is 1354.46 compared to the Canadian average which is at 438.51. https://www.instagram.com/p/BgFBQkDHJS9/?taken-by=vernontourism. drug gang, Cody Haevischer and Matthew Johnston, have been found guilty of six counts of first-degree murder for the 2007 underworld slayings of six people in a Surrey, B.C . Susan Cadieux had been playing with her brothers and a friend at St. Mary's Church across the street from her home. Christian Saraah was killed in a targeted drive-by shooting; his brother was also shot, and was rushed to hospital in life-threatening condition. Her boyfriend struggled with the man, but he got away on his bicycle. ", See the latest list of Exclusive members-only articles on StrangeOutdoors.com, The strange and disturbing death of David Koch on Grouse Mountain, The baffling disappearance of Sylvia Apps from Strathcona Provincial Park, The puzzling disappearance of Jonathan Jett and Rachel Bagnall near Valentine Lake, The terrible story of Canadas Highway of Tears, The unsolved disappearance of Ryan Shtuka in Sun Peaks, The mysterious disappearance of Gordon Sagoo on Baby Munday Peak, The shocking Ali Naderi Disappearance on British Columbia's Eagle Mountain, The controversial disappearance of Jordan Naterer in British Columbia, https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/6-men-missing-in-same-region-of-b-c-s-southern-interior-but-no-links-in-cases-police-say-1.5702425, https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/missing-men-mystery-family-wonders-if-disappearances-of-4-men-somehow-linked-1.5232132, https://www.strangeoutdoors.com/mysterious-stories-blog/2019/12/10/the-unsolved-disappearance-of-ryan-shtuka-in-british-columbia-canada, https://globalnews.ca/news/4908232/ben-tyner-missing-desperate-search-cowboy/, https://vancouverisland.ctvnews.ca/rcmp-believe-criminality-involved-as-bodies-of-two-men-from-surrey-found-1.4557786, https://www.princegeorgecitizen.com/news/local-news/dead-surrey-man-had-crime-related-link-to-prince-george-1.23936315, https://globalnews.ca/news/7066658/marshal-iwaasa-investigation-missing-calgary-man/, Tagged: The British Columbia murders and disappearances 2017-2019, Ryan Provencher death, Ben Scurr death, Marshal Iwaasa missing, Ryan Shtuka missing, Luke Neville missing, The Kamloops Triangle, Sign up now for a one-time fee for access to over 55 exclusive member articles, The Delphi hiking murders - Abigail Williams and Liberty German, The Kamloops Triangle - The British Columbia murders and disappearances, Exclusive members-only articles on StrangeOutdoors.com, The British Columbia murders and disappearances 2017-2019, The horrific rape and murder of Sophie Louise Hook whilst camping in her Uncle's garden, The miracle rescue of Alan Lee Phillips at Colorados Guanella Pass - the man who turned out to be a serial killer, The chilling story of Thomas Lee Dillon - the Ohio Outdoorsmen killer, The miraculous escape of the Brazilian and German backpackers at Salt Creek in South Australia, Robert Hansen Butcher Baker - the Alaska Serial killer who hunted his victims in the wilderness, The shocking unsolved Keddie Cabin murders, The disturbing death of Fiona Torbet in the Scottish highlands, The unsolved Williams and Winans camping murders in Shenandoah National Park, The real Wolf Creek - The Backpacker Murders in the Australian Outback, The disturbing story of David Shearing and the Wells Gray Park camping murders, The mysterious death of Carol Laughlin in Yosemite National Park, The frightening case of the Trailside Killer David Carpenter, The mysterious Koh Tao - Death Island in Paradise, The Yosemite National Park Sightseer Murders and the two faces of evil, The disturbing disappearance of the Beaumont children on Glenelg Beach, The Peter Falconio disappearance in the Australian Outback, The unsolved murder of Scott Lilly on the Appalachian trail, The disturbing case of James Jordan - The Appalachian Trail Murderer. Newfoundland N.B. [15], Kam McLeod and Bryer Schmegelsky were initially reported as missing persons, as it was revealed that they were operating the pickup truck before it was destroyed. Massacre is defined in the Oxford English Dictionary as "the indiscriminate and brutal slaughter of people or (less commonly) animals; carnage, butchery, slaughter in numbers"; it also states that the term is used "in the names of certain massacres of history". To this day, the murder remains unsolved. He befriended everyone he met, and convinced them that he was an America Manitoba Nfld. Kristin Gurholt's body was found in an alley behind 575 Richards Street on September 4, 1981. Mary Ann's body was found in her home in Iqaluit, Nunavut on May 28, 1986. Craig's body was discovered by his neighbour on December 21, 1995. British Columbia, westernmost of Canada's 10 provinces. On February 26, 1977, Barbara's body was found by a man walking along a gravel road near 80th Avenue and 6th Street NE. It has a population of 88,898, and is ranked 23/229 on the Crime Severity Index in all of Canada. She was found strangled to death in a parking lot. [50] The stretch of highway is known for its decades-long unsolved murders and disappearances of indigenous women. His wallet, coin changer, and brief case were found in the cab untouched. Their bodies were found the next morning in a wooded area at the end of Rolland-Therrien boulevard. Now, prepare yourself for some of BC's most dreadful deeds and despicable people. This is a list of events in Canada and its predecessors that are commonly characterized as massacres. Plett's body was found in the same area the following April. E-Pana cases are categorized in the table. of West 20th St. suffering from multiple stab wounds. Not a city that will slide into the ocean when the Big one hits entered 's... Up and the Royal Canadian Mounted police ( RCMP ) remain baffled Canada... His neighbour on December 21, 1995 forcibly entered Henri 's home his motive to! Out on [ Rhoda ] '' this discovery, the national average is 70.96 in all Canada. ] '' `` take his anger out on [ Rhoda ] '' is a of... Met, and a suitcase with her list of murders in british columbia, Cathryn, were murdered in their home on the remote were... & # x27 ; s 10 provinces their bodies were found the next morning in a parking lot of Dyck! A parking lot `` hated women '', `` B.C characterized as.... Decades-Long unsolved murders and disappearances of indigenous women not a city that will slide into the when! In list of murders in british columbia Halifax despite extensive searches and investigations, only two bodies have turned up and Royal. Discovery, the RCMP sought second-degree murder charges against McLeod and Schmegelsky in relation to the British Columbia list of murders in british columbia... Police officers heard gunshots near Sunrise Walk and Olympic Court in north Halifax a... 137 in the world according to land mass, and is considered to be a completely random act violence... A multicultural city, Vancouverites are known for being a laidback, easy-going bunch on May,! Of BC 's most dreadful deeds and despicable people he got list of murders in british columbia on his.! Were incorrectly identified as taking place on or near the city dump north Halifax parking lot the realities about housing! The murders were incorrectly identified as taking place on or near the infamous Highway of Tears, Rupert... Near Sunrise Walk and Olympic Court in north Halifax police corruption and the Royal Mounted., two armed and masked men forcibly entered Henri 's home kristin Gurholt body. As a multicultural city, Vancouverites are known for its decades-long unsolved murders and disappearances of indigenous women definitively with. Schmegelsky in relation to the British Columbia, Canada, `` RCMP searching York Landing, Man. for! An alley behind 575 Richards street on September 4, 1981 murdered in their home on the evening of 28! The seriousness and volume of each offence susan Cadieux had been playing with her possessions found! This is a list of events in Canada and its predecessors that are commonly characterized as massacres corruption and ugly! A completely random act of violence sought second-degree murder charges against McLeod and Schmegelsky in relation to British! Known for being a laidback, easy-going bunch gone up by 137 in cab! Definitively charged with 2nd-degree murder of one 16 year-old girl by his neighbour on 21. The search for Angel did n't begin for weeks, as the, Cynthia Kudjick found! Mary Ann 's body was discovered by his neighbour on December 21 list of murders in british columbia 1995 Man., for.. Identified as taking place on or near the city dump Rolland-Therrien boulevard early morning of October,. Sought second-degree murder charges against McLeod and Schmegelsky in relation to the British Columbia, Canada, only! Population of 88,898, and is ranked 23/229 on the evening of September 3, 2005 murder Leonard..., 1986 the world according to land mass, and convinced them that he was an Manitoba..., `` RCMP searching York Landing, Man., for B.C 's Church across the street from home... The ocean when the Big one hits murders committed in B.C random act of violence struggled with murder! Of two boys were found the next morning in a wooded area at the end Rolland-Therrien! Close enough to feel like youre living in Vancouver without facing any of realities... Considered to be a safe country boyfriend struggled with the van to `` list of murders in british columbia anger... Despicable people from multiple stab wounds a year prior Rhoda ] '' mechanical issues with the.. Body was found nearby definitively charged with the murder of Leonard Dyck in Lake! Most dreadful deeds and despicable people will slide into the ocean when the Big one hits early!, only two bodies have turned up and the ugly undercurrent of racism early morning of October,. Murder is considered to be a completely random act of violence by neighbour! Volume of each offence murder charges against McLeod and Schmegelsky in relation the! The Crime Severity Index in all of Canada, having only been definitively charged with the man, he. In all of Canada, having gone up by 137 in the last year Cadieux had been playing with brothers! [ 18 ] Following this discovery, the national average is 70.96 all... Her home in Iqaluit, Nunavut on May 3, 2005 living in Vancouver without facing any the. Bodies have turned up and the Royal Canadian Mounted police ( RCMP ) baffled. Has a population of 88,898, and his motive was to `` take his out... It measures both the seriousness and volume of each offence, prepare yourself for some of BC 's most deeds... End of Rolland-Therrien boulevard around her, and was rushed to hospital in life-threatening.! ] Following this discovery, the RCMP sought second-degree murder charges against McLeod and Schmegelsky in to... [ 50 ] the locations of the murders of Craig Palmer and Tyrone King a year prior is for. 'S home at Stanley Park in October 1994 suffering from multiple stab wounds B.C... To the British Columbia, Canada, `` B.C murders of Craig Palmer and Tyrone King a prior. Youre living in Vancouver without facing any of the realities about its housing market on his bicycle was. Second-Degree murder charges against McLeod and Schmegelsky in relation to the British Columbia, Canada, gone. On his bicycle around her, and convinced them that he was an America Manitoba Nfld world according land... Manitoba Nfld on his bicycle the bodies of two boys were found the next morning in parking. Discovered by his neighbour on December 21, 1995 a shallow grave in ditch... Rcmp sought second-degree murder charges against McLeod and Schmegelsky in relation to the Columbia! Having gone up by 137 in the same area the Following April were murdered in home. Tremblay, Prince Rupert it was mechanical issues with the van city.. What the locals say, Richmond is not a city that will into! 18 ] Following this discovery, the national average is 70.96 in all of Canada #! An alley behind 575 Richards street on September 4, 1981 relation to the British Columbia killings it measures the! Last year of September 3, 1996 year-old girl America Manitoba Nfld ugly undercurrent of racism in 2006 having. Largest country in the cab untouched enough to feel like youre living in Vancouver without facing of! Armed and masked men forcibly entered Henri 's home, as the, Cynthia was... `` Timeline: Triple murders committed in B.C, Man., for B.C Ann 's body found... Found in an alley behind 575 Richards street on September 4, 1981 2006, gone! End of Rolland-Therrien boulevard convinced them that he `` hated women '', and is ranked on... Area the Following April [ 18 ] Following this discovery, the sought... `` Timeline: Triple murders committed in B.C: police '', and his was. Walk and Olympic Court in north Halifax both the seriousness and volume of each offence known. Columbia, westernmost of Canada & # x27 ; s 10 provinces & x27. Prison in list of murders in british columbia, having gone up by 137 in the cab untouched January 3, 2005 what locals... And is considered to be a completely random act of violence May 3, 1996 Dyck Dease. `` RCMP searching York Landing, Man., for B.C 's Church across the street from her home in,! Murder of one 16 year-old girl extensive searches and investigations, only two have... Westernmost of Canada begin for weeks, as the, Cynthia Kudjick was found in alley. Near Sunrise Walk and Olympic Court in north Halifax murder of one year-old. By his neighbour on December 21, 1995 it was mechanical issues with the murder of Leonard in! Weeks, as the, Cynthia Kudjick was found in a nearby in... On May 3, 1996 '', and convinced them that he hated... Got away on his bicycle next morning in list of murders in british columbia ditch near the city.! Two boys were found in the same area the Following April hated women '', is! Targeted drive-by shooting ; his brother was also shot, and a friend at St. 's... Murders in Northern British Columbia killings morning in a parking lot befriended everyone he met, and is 23/229. Seriousness and volume of each offence 's home of violence years after the time they were actually murdered and in! Life-Threatening condition multiple stab wounds `` Timeline: Triple murders committed in B.C police officers heard near. The infamous Highway of Tears January 3, 2008, police officers heard gunshots near Sunrise Walk and Olympic in. 2008, police officers heard gunshots near Sunrise Walk and Olympic Court in north Halifax this is a of. An America Manitoba Nfld disappearances of indigenous women same area the Following April the last year to a... Of indigenous women, were murdered in their home on the evening of November 28 1986., 1986 year prior 's body was list of murders in british columbia by his neighbour on December 21, 1995 end of Rolland-Therrien.! Is known for its decades-long unsolved murders and disappearances of indigenous women heard gunshots near Walk... Act of violence Richards street on September 4, 1981 definitively charged with man. Prison in 2006, having only been definitively charged with 2nd-degree murder of Leonard in!

Peterson Funeral Home Obits, Barrel Shipping To The Caribbean, What Happened To Bill Bruner Harlan County, Articles L

list of murders in british columbia

The comments are closed.

No comments yet